The bryophyte community as bioindicator of heavy metals in a waterfall outflow


Physicochemical properties of waterfall stream

The environmental parameters of the Huay Pah Lahd waterfall stream are shown in Table 1. The water at the sampling site was shallow (0.4–1 m). Temperatures in water samples ranged from 20 to 33 °C, while water temperature along the bank of Pharadorn waterfall, located downstream of Romklao waterfall in Phu Hin Rong Kla National Park, was 25 °C6. While low water temperature and low light intensity are important for bryophyte development and influence primary productivity, nutrient enrichment in plant media (e.g., soil, sediment) is the most important factor for bryophyte growth7.

Table 1 Physicochemical properties of Pah Lahd stream.

The quantities of nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N), total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN) and phosphate (PO43−) in the waterfall stream were 1.01, < 4.0, and 0.02 mg L−1, respectively, while ammonia–nitrogen (NH3-N) was undetectable. Excessive concentrations of phosphorus and nitrogen compounds, which are limiting factors and essential nutrients for aquatic life, can cause eutrophication. However, dilution effects during the rainy season in lotic ecosystems are a key factor in causing low nutrient concentrations in water bodies8. Rainfall strongly affected the physicochemical properties of the water because flow rate, depth, and water level, and nutrient run-off (and/or pollutant run-off) changed during the sampling period in the May to October Southwest Monsoon rainy season. During rainy periods in 2020, total rainfall and mean temperature in Chiang Mai Province were approximately 3475 mm and 28.8 °C, respectively9. While most heavy metal concentrations (Cu, Cd, Zn, Fe, Cr, Pb and Mn) in water samples were relatively low to undetectable, Ni was detected at 0.056 mg L−1. Furthermore, F and Cl contents were < 0.15 and 6.2 mg L−1, respectively, which are considered low according to permissible limits set by the World Health Organization (WHO) at 0.6–1.5 mg L−1 and 250 mg L−1, respectively10. Total organic carbon (TOC) content of the water sample was below the detection limit (< 0.05 mg L−1), which is due to the low level of hydrocarbon contaminants in the water sources11.

Total solids content is a direct measurement of the total mass of organic and inorganic particles suspended in water, as well as total dissolved ions12. A high total solids content in waters is the most likely cause of increased total hardness. Other possible sources of increased hard water content include Ca, Mg and heavy metals widely distributed in rocks and sediments13. The water in Pah Lahd stream was naturally soft (total hardness 31.7 mg L−1) with very low total solids and minerals. Soft water is defined as a water sample having a low amount of calcium carbonate14.

The pH value of the studied stream was near neutral (≈ 6.8). Slightly acidic water (~ pH 5–6) occurs naturally, enabling some heavy metals that are adsorbed to mineral surfaces to be dissolved in aquatic ecosystems, as well as enhancing mineral dissolution in sediment15. A pH range of 6.5 to 9.0 provide acceptable protection for survival of freshwater biota, implying that there is no detriment to the ecosystem or biota in the current study16. The DO level of the study site (5.03 mg L−1) was nearly equivalent to the DO water quality standard in a Thai waterfall stream (6 mg L−1)17; nevertheless, a reduction in DO levels might be linked to human activities, i.e., the presence of relatively large numbers of tourists and improper waste disposal17. High flow velocity and turbulence of a waterfall increases DO content18. Biological oxygen demand (BOD) is another important indicator of water quality, as it measures the quantity of oxygen required for microbial respiration and biological degradation of organic matter in water. Reduced BOD levels imply that the quantity of organic substances is promoting the growth of microbial populations, thus enhancing the available DO content for aquatic life19. The water sample in the current study had a low BOD level (< 1 mg L−1), indicating that the waterfall ecosystem had good water quality.

Bryophyte taxa in the study site

A total of eight bryophytes were collected from different microhabitats and life modes. These constituted two major taxonomic groupings (1) mosses: epilithic or rupicolous mosses (three acrocarpous mosses: Hyophila involuta (Hook.) A. Jaeger (Pottiaceae), Scopelophila cataractae (Mitt.) Broth. (Pottiaceae) and Bryum sp. (Bryaceae); three aquatic mosses (one acrocarpous moss, Fissidens crispulus Brid. var. crispulus (Fissidentaceae) and two pleurocarpous mosses: Claopodium prionophyllum (Müll. Hal.) Broth. (Leskeaceae), and Ectropothecium zollingeri (Müll. Hal.) A. Jaeger (Hypnaceae); and (2) liverworts: one thalloid liverwort, Marchantia emarginata Reinw. Blume & Nees var. emarginata (Marchantiaceae); and one leafy liverwort: Porella acutifolia (Lehm. & Lindenb.) Trevis. var. birmanica S. Hatt. (Porellaceae).

The species area curves showed a smooth curvature, but did not reach an asymptote (Fig. 1). The sampling completeness (approximately 80.8%) also indicated that 27 subplots from the three 10-m plots were adequate for estimating the bryophyte diversity in the Huay Pah Lahd stream (Table 2 and Fig. 2). According to the Jackknife estimate of the total number of taxa, the number of expected species for the community was between 7 and 10. Furthermore, bryophyte diversity and coverage in the three study plots showed similar patterns (Table 2). Plot 3 had the lowest species richness (5 taxa) and Shannon–Wiener diversity index (1.31), whereas Plot 1 had the highest species richness (8 taxa) and Shannon–Wiener diversity index (1.67). The Pielou’s evenness index was relatively similar among the plots, ranging from 0.79 to 0.81 (total = 0.54), whereas the coverage of bryophytes in the three study plots ranged from 48.54 to 53.85%. Despite being sampled in the same season (wet), habitat heterogeneity and differing environmental conditions among the three plots cause differences in the composition and structure of bryophytes.

Figure 1
figure 1

Species area curve showing relationship in numbers of subplot and numbers of species of bryophytes in Huay Pah Lahd stream, Doi Suthep-Pui national park.

Table 2 Bryophyte diversity of three sampling plots (10-m2 per plot) along Huay Pah Lahd stream, Doi Suthep-Pui national park.
Figure 2
figure 2

Rare species (A) and dominant taxa (B-D) of mosses grown on wet rocks in Huay Pah Lahd stream outflow, Doi Suthep-Pui national park: (A) S. cataractae; (B) E. zolligeri; (C) F. crispulus var. crispulus; and (D) C. prionophyllum.

A previous study in forest (Kanghe Provincial Nature Reserve, Guangdong Province, China) revealed a significantly higher number of ground bryophytes (37 taxa) and a Shannon-Weiner index value of up to 2.9, whereas the present study in the waterfall stream found a significantly lower number of bryophytes (4.6 times) and Shannon-Weiner index value (2.6 times), respectively20. To some extent, the specialized habitat of bryophytes, such as cave, has been discovered, with a similar number of species and diversity index to this study; however, it had lesser bryophyte coverage because light intensity is a limiting factor in caves, which may affect plant growth and development21.

There were three dominant lithophytic mosses, which are aquatic, semi-aquatic, or found on soil and rock near seasonally dried streams of the Huay Pah Lahd waterfalls. These bryophytes can survive on muddy, debris-covered rocks, which are flooded during the rainy season and which dry up during the hot-dry season (February to April), viz. E. zollingeri, F. crispulus var. crispulus, and C. prionophyllum (Fig. 2B-D). Of the eight observed bryophyte taxa (Table 3), Fissidens crispulus var. crispulus was the most dominant taxon in the waterfall stream, with an importance value (IV) of 28.98%, relative frequency (RF) of 20.59%, and relative cover (RC) of 37.37% (Fig. 2C). This moss taxon is a rheophyte that can be found in wet rocks of waterfall streams throughout Indochina during the rainy season22. Other dominant bryophyte taxa with IV ≥ 10% include E. zollingeri, C. prionophyllum, and H. involuta (Table 3 and Fig. 2B, D). These moss taxa can be found in various moist or semi-wet locations, including waterfall ecosystems23,24. Furthermore, S. cataractae can be regarded a rare moss species because it had the lowest IV (0.91%), and was found in only one subplot with an extremely low value of relative cover (RC = 0.36%) (Table 3 and Fig. 2A). Scopelophila cataractae is a rare species found in Thailand that is listed as endangered species in the IUCN Red List’s threatened category25,26. Scopelophila cataractae is found in various parts of the world including China, Korea, Japan, Papua New Guinea, and North and South America27,28. A protonemal colony of S. cataractae was observed at the same time (June, during the rainy season) and same study site as in the previous study26. Narrow, light-green patches of the protonemata occur along the wet rocks (c. 50 cm height) in streams, together with colonies of other bryophytes such as H. involuta. The colony consisted of numerous filamentous protonema which produced shoots of S. cataractae with multicellular gemmae in the axils of young leaves.

Table 3 Bryophyte community composition and structure of Huay Pah Lahd stream, Doi Suthep-Pui national park.

Porella acutifolia var. birmanica was first discovered in Burma and is widespread in Burma, Vietnam, Laos, and Thailand29,30. This taxon has been reported from Doi Suthep and Ru See (Hermit) cave in Doi Suthep-Pui National Park, at elevations of about 1100–1200 m29. Hyophila involuta, Bryum sp., and M. emarginata may be termed pioneer taxa in open and urban environments. Hyophila involuta occurs in a very wide variety of habitats including deserts, humid region soil, wet rocks, and waterfall stream banks, an even as on concrete structures in urban settings24,31,32. Unfortunately, the Bryum sp. specimen lacked sporophyte materials; thus, it was not possible to identify it to the species level. Members of the Bryaceae family, on the other hand, are abundant in urban and disturbed regions across the world, and can be seen growing with potted plants33. Marchantia emarginata var. emarginata, a cosmopolitan taxon of thalloid liverwort34, is abundant in soils and on rocks near stream banks and other locations in Chiang Mai Province.

Heavy metal concentrations in bryophyte tissues and substrates

Bryophytes, which lack true roots and have a thick cuticle, take advantage of a high surface/volume ratio and a high cation-exchange capacity, allowing capillary action to transport available minerals and water to the entire surface35. Furthermore, phyllids (leaf-like structures) and thalli of bryophytes have highly absorbent surfaces and an absence of waxy cuticle over the laminal surfaces. As a consequence, cell walls readily absorb moisture and a wide range of minerals and metal ions from water that flows over the plant36. Among our specimens (Table 4), Cu levels in tissues ranged from 8.5 mg kg−1 (P. acutifolia var. birmanica gametophyte) to 530.1 mg kg−1 (S. cataractae protonema); Cd from 4.8 mg kg−1 (E. zollingeri gametophyte) to 16.9 mg kg−1 (S. cataractae protonema); Zn from 129.4 mg kg−1 (H. involuta gametophyte) to 1187.2 mg kg−1 (S. cataractae protonema); Fe from 3962.5 mg kg−1 (H. involuta gametophyte) to 8026.7 mg kg−1 (S. cataractae protonema); and Mn from 143.3 mg kg−1 (S. cataractae gametophyte) to 504.6 mg kg−1 (C. prionophyllum gametophyte).

Table 4 Heavy metal accumulation in bryophyte tissues (n = 3).

The gametophytes of S. cataractae had considerably greater Cu accumulation (p < 0.05) or approximately 3.7–59 times greater than among other bryophytes, although protonema of S. cataractae had an even higher Cu concentration (p > 0.05). Because it accumulated Cu primarily in gametophyte tissue, S. cataractae is categorized as a hyperaccumulator of Cu37. Copper is an essential nutrient that is required for plant development and growth. It plays a significant role in regulating physiological functions such as the photosynthetic and respiratory electron transport chains, nitrogen fixation, protein metabolism, antioxidant production, the ROS defense system, cell wall metabolism, and hormone perception, and acts as an essential cofactor for numerous metalloproteins38. At the cellular level, however, excessive Cu concentrations are harmful to plants due to inactivation and disruption of enzyme activity or protein functions38. Gametophytes of S. cataractae accumulated substantial quantities of Cd, Zn and Fe, with concentrations of 9.2 mg kg−1, 846.1 mg kg−1 and 5434.3 mg kg−1, respectively. Scopelophila cataractae has been shown to accumulate substantial amounts of heavy metals such as Cd, Cu and Zn in contaminated soil (e.g., Cu tailings)39. Remarkably low Cu concentrations were detected in C. prionophyllum and H. involuta (10.3 kg−1 and 9.6 mg kg−1, respectively).

Highest Cu concentrations were measured in sediment substrate of shoot colonies and protonemal colonies of S. cataractae (251.6 mg kg−1 and 239.4 mg kg−1, respectively) (p < 0.05), whereas substantial Fe concentrations were found in sediment substrate of gametophyte colonies of H. involuta (3127.1 mg kg−1) (p < 0.05) and sediment substrate of protonemal colonies, shoot colonies and decayed moss of S. cataractae (2345.3, 2289.4 and 1963.7 mg kg−1, respectively) (Table 5). Copper concentrations in substrates of S. cataractae and water were generally in the following order: sediment substrate > rock > water. According to recent research, growth substrate is a key source of heavy metals in stream environments; this may have led to increased absorption and accumulation of Al, Cu and Zn in leaf surfaces and protonemata of S. cataractae gametophytes26. Cadmium and Zn concentrations in rock substrates of S. cataractae and P. acutifolia var. birmanica were low (0.5 and 0.3 mg kg−1 for Cd, and 34.9 and 31.2 mg kg−1 for Zn, respectively). Heavy metal (Cu, Fe and Mn) concentrations in rock substrates of P. acutifolia var. birmanica were similar to those of rock substrates of S. cataractae. Both were located in similar environments and so received heavy metals from similar sources and mechanisms.

Table 5 Heavy metal accumulation in bryophyte substrates (n = 3).

Heavy metal localization in bryophyte tissues implies the suitability of these organisms for biomonitoring freshwater pollution40,41. The accumulation potential of heavy metals in cell walls of bryophytes can be linked to degree of tolerance and resistance to heavy metals. The substantial heavy metal concentrations that bind to pectin is considered to be an effective defensive mechanism against divalent metal cations such as Cu2+ and Pb2+, allowing for successful adaptation to heavy metal-enriched substrates41.

Many bryophyte taxa have been tested for their tolerance and accumulation capabilities at both laboratory and field scales. For example, Bryum radiculosum Brid. (Bryaceae) grown in industrial areas of Portoscuso (Sardinia, Italy) has been used as bioindicator for trace elements such as Pb, Cd and Zn, with accumulation rates at 61–2141 mg kg−1, 3–40.6 mg kg−1 and 32–2360 mg kg−1, respectively35. Bryum radiculosum from a previous study that grew in locations exposed to heavy metals from Cu-containing pesticides in vineyards. This moss taxon accumulated considerably lower amounts of Cu than Bryum sp. in the present study (135.3 mg kg−1), or less than 1.4–13.5-fold42. Furthermore, P. acutifolia var. birmanica, C. prionophyllum and Bryum sp. accumulated substantial Fe (6877.6 mg kg−1, 6370 mg kg−1 and 5869.9 mg kg−1, respectively), and Cd (12 mg kg−1, 8.2 mg kg−1 and 6.2 mg kg−1, respectively), and modest amounts of Zn (161.3 mg kg−1, 226.9 mg kg−1 and 225.5 mg kg−1, respectively). Cadmium is a hazardous metal; Cd exposure in moss media at 10 μM inhibited photosynthesis and caused nutrient deficiencies, leading to chlorosis in gametophyte tissues of Physcomitrium patens (Hedw.) Mitt. (Funariaceae) and aquatic moss, Fontinalis antipyretica Hedw. (Fontinalaceae)43. Zinc and Fe are major components of numerous enzymes and proteins in plants and are thus essential micronutrients for biota. High concentrations of Zn and Fe, on the other hand, can be toxic to moss cells, affecting the entire plant by decreasing moss growth and development44.

In the present study, substantial Mn concentrations were detected in gametophytic tissues of C. prionophyllum, Bryum sp., H. involuta and F. crispulus var. crispulus (504.6 mg kg−1, 482.6 mg kg−1, 467.2 mg kg−1 and 448.6 mg kg−1, respectively). Manganese accumulation in the study bryophytes were much higher (144.3–504.6 mg kg−1) compared to those in four moss taxa Bryum argenteum Hedw. (Bryaceae), Bryum capillare Hedw. (Bryaceae), Brachythecium sp. (Brachytheciaceae), and Hypnum cupressiforme Hedw. (Hypnaceae) grown in various locations (roadside, populated areas, forests, croplands); Mn accumulation (0.1–8.6 mg kg−1)45. Excessive Mn concentration in plant tissues can induce oxidative stress, alter enzymatic activity, absorption and accumulation of nutrients, and translocation of certain elements including calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), Fe and phosphorus (P)46.

The rediscovery of P. acutifolia var. birmanica in Huay Pah Lahd stream after a half-century29 may suggest that the Doi Suthep-Pui National Park still serves as a haven for sensitive bryophytes, and is minimally affected by anthropogenic activities and thus can support a suitable habitat for bryophytes. Nonetheless, anthropogenic activities around the sampling location may have introduced heavy metals into sediment and water, increasing heavy metal absorption and accumulation in bryophyte tissue26. Because P. acutifolia var. birmanica also accumulated substantial heavy metals, particularly Cd, the presence of this leafy liverwort may be used as bioindicator in future research for monitoring changes in environmental patterns of stream ecosystems.

Enrichment factors of heavy metals

The EFs of heavy metals were generally in the following order: Cd > Zn > Mn > Cu (Fig. 3). Significant EFs of all the studied heavy metals (5.3, 2.4 and 0.9 for EFZn, EFCd and EFCu, respectively) were found in S. cataractae (p < 0.05), except for EFMn (0.3). A previous study found that EFs of Cu, Cd, and Zn increased as the quantities of heavy metals in moss tissue increased47. This was not the case in the current study, however. This finding could be due to differences in moss tolerance and adaption35. The fact that EFs < 5 for study plants indicates that the sources of these metals are lithologic, i.e., sediment, water, and rock40. Furthermore, the EFZn > 5 for S. cataractae indicated that Zn contamination at the sampling site ranged between low and moderate. Zinc is readily absorbed by plants in high quantities due to its abundance in the lithosphere as well as its moderate solutability, but it is rarely toxic to plants48. The EF of Mn for H. involuta was low, but nevertheless had the highest value (1.1; p < 0.05), followed by P. acutifolia (1.0). According to Ali Hussen et al.3, tourist activities are now regarded as key sources of heavy metals in waterfall streams, the resultant water contamination often exceeding the standard for drinking water. Because the study site was close to hill-tribe villages and tourist sites, pollutant contamination in waterfall steam from anthropogenic activities was likewise expected.

Figure 3
figure 3

Means for the enrichment factor (EF) of Cu, Cd, Zn and Mn (A-D) with corresponding standard deviations (SD) for four elements in bryophytes relative to the sediment substrates.

Each bryophyte taxon has specific habitat and environmental preferences and a unique ecological niche. These factors, in combination with their sensitivity to environmental change, and propensity to take up and accumulate pollutants from soil and water, and accumulate trace metals (Cd, Pb, Ni and Cr) from the atmosphere, soil and water in contaminated areas worldwide make bryophyte taxa useful indicators of vegetation alteration and climate change and the overall health status of habitats49,50. To date, few studies exist which investigate bryophytes as bioindicators of heavy metals in both terrestrial and aquatic environments in Thailand.



Source link

Ozinize
Logo
Shopping cart