CDC advisers recommend resuming use of J&J’s coronavirus vaccine; FDA to add blood clot warning
Vaccine advisers to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention voted Friday to recommend resuming use of the vaccine.
An updated warning will be added to the label.
The CDC and US Food and Drug Administration recommended pausing the use of the vaccine on April 13 while they investigated the risk of rare, severe blood clots. On Friday, members of the CDC’s Advisory Committee for Immunization Practices agreed the benefits of the vaccine outweigh the risks from rare blood clots linked with the vaccine.
Committee members worried that taking one of only three vaccines out of the mix available to Americans would slow efforts to immunize the population against a virus that has killed more than half a million people in the United States. Plus, they agreed that having a one-shot vaccine that doesn’t need to be stored in freezers was valuable and would be preferred by many people who do not want to come back for a second dose, or who would struggle to make two vaccination appointments.
The vote was 10 in favor, four opposed, with one abstention.
“This is a very rare event — a very rare event,” Dr. Jose Romero, who chairs ACIP and who is also the top health official for Arkansas, told the meeting. He noted that vaccinating more people would prevent Covid-19 deaths, but would also prevent other problems, including mental health consequences of infections and so-called long Covid syndrome, in which survivors experience months of symptoms.
“Limiting the vaccine for a greater population certainly would have an impact on that,” he said.
The panel debated various possibilities, including recommending restricted use of the vaccine, but finally voted simply on the option to recommend use of the vaccine as it had been before — in all adults over the age of 18.The language of the vote: “The Janssen Covid-19 vaccine is recommended for persons 18 years of age and older in the U.S. population under the FDA’s emergency use authorization.”
The US Food and Drug Administration will update the label for the vaccine, indicating that women under the age of 50 should be aware of the risk of a rare blood clotting syndrome associated with the vaccine.
Earlier, Johnson & Johnson officials said they had agreed to new language for the label that acknowledges the risk of thrombosis with thrombocytopenia syndrome, or TTS.
Some members of the committee were unhappy with the decision and the vote was not unanimous. Four members voted against the recommendation.
“I did not object to the recommendation; I objected to the absence of any kind of guidance from us,” said Dr. Sarah Long, a professor of pediatrics at Drexel University College of Medicine.
Of the 15 US cases of rare blood clots associated with the J&J vaccine, 13 were in women under the age of 50. ACIP discussed the need to give women in this age group an extra warning, but in the end left it out of the vote.
“This is an age group that is most at risk, that is getting this vaccine predominantly to save other people’s lives and morbidity, not their own,” Long said. “And I think we have a responsibility to be certain that they know this, and if they choose to be vaccinated with this anyhow, we want to respect that choice.”
Dr. Pablo Sanchez, a pediatrician at Ohio State University, also wanted ACIP to include more guidance with its recommendation. “I have no problem with the continued availability of this vaccine,” he said. “But I think that we are just making a blanket recommendation,” he added. “I think we have to have stronger language.”
Dr. Grace Lee, a professor of pediatrics at Stanford University, voted for the recommendation but said she understood the no votes. “I absolutely think this is a serious adverse event. We need to continue to ensure that awareness is raised,” she said. “I also think that we have to come out with a clearer recommendation.”
But other ACIP members said the country needs the vaccine.
“I think the risks and benefits of this vaccine clearly show that we’re preventing tremendous disease, and that we need to be cognitive of that fact,”said Dr. Jason Goldman, a physician in private practice in Coral Spring, Florida, who is not a voting member of the committee.
“Many of my patients are expressing a preference for the vaccine for a single dose because they cannot take off from work,” added Goldman. “I am gravely concerned that if we do not continue with the vaccine, it is going to dramatically reduce the ability of my patients to get vaccinated.”
CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky will sign off on ACIP’s recommendation and then FDA will prepare an amended emergency use authorization for the vaccine, Dr. Amanda Cohn, ACIP’s executive secretary, told the meeting.
“We are awaiting and anticipate that the FDA will be putting out a new, a newly approved EUA language,” Cohn said.
“And additionally, we will be taking the input from today, along with this language that FDA will publish and both FDA and CDC will have communication materials and education materials including infographics, patient fact sheets.”
Next week the CDC has scheduled a telephone briefing for doctors and other clinicians to explain the changed recommendations and lay out the symptoms of and treatments for TTS. Most patients with TTS develop a severe headache days to weeks after getting the vaccine, doctors told ACIP.
There will also be a Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report — the CDC’s main publication for disseminating health news — to share the information.
American Medical Association president Dr. Susan Bailey said her organization would help get the word out about risks.
“The population-level data presented during ACIP’s meeting today clearly demonstrates that the benefits of this approach outweigh the risks, which include becoming infected with COVID-19 and the potential for severe illness or death,” Bailey said.
“The AMA will continue to work with the FDA and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to ensure physicians and patients are aware of the rare, but increased risk of thrombosis with thrombocytopenia syndrome (TTS) in women under the age of 50, as well as the appropriate treatment, so they can act quickly.”
Blood clots are common, but TTS is especially rare. It involves an unusual immune reaction that targets platelets, which are cells involved in blood clotting. Antibodies latch onto the platelets, pulling them out of circulation and causing them to clump together. The result is blood clots along with a low platelet count.
Treatment includes using blood thinner, but not heparin, as well as an immune product called IVIG to regulate the antibody response.
Risks and benefits
The CDC’s Dr. Sara Oliver presented the results of several models laying out what might happen if the vaccine is used again, including with restrictions on use in certain groups. The CDC took into consideration deaths from coronavirus and the likelihood that people would get vaccinated more quickly if the Janssen vaccine was in the mix.
“When resuming vaccination among all persons at least 18 years, we expect 26 to 45 TTS cases depending on vaccine uptake,” she said. But 600 to 1,400 deaths from Covid-19 would be prevented, and as many as 3,500 ICU admissions would be prevented.
If the vaccine were restricted to people over the age of 50, three TTS cases could be expected, but between 40 and 250 Covid-19 deaths would be prevented, and as many as 1,000 people would not need treatment in the ICU.
For every million doses of vaccine given to women 18 to 49, 13 TTS cases can be expected, Oliver said. But 12 deaths from Covid-19 would be prevented and 127 ICU admissions would be prevented among those women if they had access to the Janssen vaccine.
American Society of Hematology president Dr. Martin Tallman, a specialist at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, said Covid-19 carries a much higher risk of blood clots than any vaccine.
“In fact, COVID-19 infection carries a much higher risk of blood clots —147,000 in 1 million hospitalized COVID-19 patients experience clots, compared to roughly two in 1 million individuals who received the Johnson & Johnson vaccine,” Tallman said in a statement.
Moderna’s and Pfizer’s vaccines have not been linked with blood clots at all, the ACIP panel heard.
The CDC did not consider a gender-based restriction, Oliver said, because it would be too hard to explain — even though the risk of blood clots appears to be very low among men.
Dr. Paul Offit, who is a vaccine adviser to the FDA and a pediatrician at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, said he thought the CDC did a good job of laying out the risks of the vaccine versus the risks of Covid-19.
“This was the CDC at its finest,” Offit told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer.